The more I hear about the changes that are coming to the Canadian EI system, the more frustrated I get. And it’s not even the changes themselves that are making me the most angry (though there’s definitely some rage there); it’s the comments I keep hearing from people who support the changes, or think the changes should be even harsher. The most common comment I’ve heard is that Atlantic Canadians (and our seasonal workers in particular) are lazy bums sponging off the system several months a year, and that we should be forced to suck it up and either get a job flipping burgers or move out West for work.
Funny how sure of themselves are these people who have stable jobs and don’t have to deal with being regularly unemployed themselves. They’re so angry about people “abusing” the system that they pay for (uh, hello, the same people “abusing” the system pay EI premiums too, you know) that they don’t stop to think for a moment about some of the comments they’re making.
A few points, if you will:
– Yes, our seasonal workers (fishermen, tourism workers, agriculturists, etc) “sponge” off the system every year. That’s because their jobs, the jobs they’ve worked all their lives and are trained for, don’t enable them to work 12 months out of the year. I’ve heard so many comments about how those people should “look for other work then, if their jobs are so unsteady”. And that is one of the most ridiculously stupid things I’ve ever heard. If all the fishermen suddenly packed up and said, “You know what? We should go find a job that’s available all year through” who the hell would catch your fish?! Like it or not, seasonal work is required work. Those seasonal workers catch your fish, harvest your crops, cut your lumber, and a host of other things that need doing. Cut them out of the equation and you create a massive deficit in freakin’ society.
– “Okay, so don’t make them find new jobs, but force them to take other jobs during the off months!” Do you really think that’s so easy? First of all, most of these seasonal workers are only trained in the job they do. In order to find a secondary job that pays them at least closed to what they make normally, they would need to be trained in something. Who is going to pay to train them? Do you remember what college costs? Because it’s gone up. A lot. The EI changes that are coming will put no money into helping retrain the unemployed. So where is that money going to come from? Believe it or not, not everyone can afford to just say, “Hey, I think I’ll go back to college so I can work two jobs a year.”
– “Okay, screw a career, just make them work at McDonald’s in the off months!” Oh, you sad, sorry little person. There are currently tens of thousands of seasonal workers in Nova Scotia. Do you honestly believe that there are tens of thousands of unskilled jobs just sitting around waiting to be filled? Particularly in Nova Scotia? Because if you do, I’ll pray for your sanity if you ever lose your job. It hasn’t been very long since I was a college student looking for part-time work to help pay my tuition, so I know what it’s like. It’s not uncommon to hand out a hundred resumes before getting one interview (and that’s in the cities, not the super-rural areas many of us live in). And I’m going to explain something to you right now: minimum wage employers like fast food joints and department stores don’t want to hire you if they know you’re going to be leaving for another job in a few months. Why would McDonald’s want to hire a fisherman and spend a bunch of money training him, knowing that he’s going to leave to go back to fishing in a few short months? Minimum wage employers don’t want to deal with that nonsense anymore than any other employer would. Turnover at those places is bad enough without hiring people that they know for sure aren’t sticking around for very long. And as previously mentioned, even if some seasonal workers do manage to pick up these types of jobs, there aren’t enough available for everyone. To think that there are is complete and utter folly. If there were that many minimum wage jobs just sitting around, students wouldn’t have such a hard time finding part-time and summer jobs.
The entire thing, in my opinion (and many other people’s opinions) smacks of trying to force as many people out west as possible. If seasonal workers (and others who claim EI regularly for other reasons) are forced to take jobs outside their pay grade (and yes, 70% of what you’re used to is significantly reduced pay when you’re fixed into things like mortgages and vehicle loans), then they’re going to start looking at greener pastures, which seems to be exactly what the feds want. The West will continue to grow and prosper, while the East steadily collapses. The more people who head out to the oil sands for better-paying work, the less money that will be spent in Nova Scotia, the higher our taxes will rise, and so on and so forth. And to all you people who support the changes, you who have steady, well-paying jobs and never have to rely on EI yourselves…you can be damn sure that as the Nova Scotia economy rapidly declines, your jobs will end up in jeopardy as well.
Will you be ready and willing to take a minimum wage job or uproot your entire life to move out West?
No Page Left Blank 
Yes, oh my god, yes, can I just make out with this entire post? I swear to god I almost had a rage blackout when I heard about the EI changes. It could not be any more insultingly obvious what the purpose behind them is (to drive people out west, like you said), especially when just a few months ago something similar was being proposed in BC to send people to jobs up north. There was more outright public discussion and dismissal of that idea at the time, so it’s hard not to see their tethering a similar proposal to EI and taking advantage of people’s irrational fear and hatred of EI recipients as anything other than a way to make it more palatable.
It’s also incredibly insulting to blame seasonal workers for this because it’s not as though they’re the ones who created seasonal jobs! Seasonal work, part time work, shift work, and large pools of underemployed people aren’t an accident; they’re explicitly what allow employers to drive their labour costs down to the lowest possible level. The people who fill all these jobs are performing exactly as expected in our economic system – even the unemployed! – so it drives me crazy to hear people talk about them like they’re a totally unexpected problem instead of an expected byproduct.
…Obviously I have a lot of really strong feelings on this subject, haha. 😀 It’s really kind of awe-inspiring when you see the vicious anti-EI sentiment leaking through these sorts of discussions though. I think there’s a lot to be said for looking at that kind of irrational fear as an expression of our collective insecurity. By framing someone’s un/deremployment as solely the result of individual efforts and failures (as opposed to something that’s 100% expected and actually vital to the current economic system), people can feel falsely secure about themselves, because that must mean they did something *right*, and since they’ll never do anything *wrong* and nothing bad and out of their control will ever, ever happen to them, they’ll never be poor! This is basic psychology – when things go right, we always assume it’s because of our own inherent awesomeness, something *we* did, so obviously when other people aren’t doing as well that must be something they did too.
And none of this is even speaking of what a completely awesome idea it is to funnel all our labour into one sector/region, I mean I hear oil is an infinite resource you guys, I can’t imagine what could possibly go wrong with this idea, shhhh nobody ask Ontario’s manufacturing sector what happened to all their jobs when the recession hit (◕‿◕✿)
Okay I’m reduced to passive-agressive emoticons now, I should go
You know I love you, right? ❤
So much win to your second paragraph. This is the exact kind of thing I was trying to impress with my "who the hell is going to catch your fish?!" comment. People who aren't on EI and feel somehow cheated because OTHER people get to go on EI act like seasonal workers are lazy bums who chose those jobs specifically because they knew they'd get part of the year off. They don't seem to be able to realize that those jobs are DESIGNED that way and that SOMEONE damn well has to do them! I'm sure lots of the fishermen (because I like to pick on them) in Nova Scotia would love to be able to work year round and make more money, but that's just not the way fishing works, at least not in colder climates.
Also, your third paragraph is a sea of loveliness. We're all guilty of this, but it is so true that people with great, secure, high-paying jobs have an awful habit of thinking that they got that job because they worked and fought and struggled, and that anyone with a crappy job has it because they suck and aren't trying hard enough. Hate to break it to you, but that Big Mac you're eating? A lot of minimum wage jobs exist to bring you that piece of filth, and SOMEONE has fill those jobs. On the alternate side of things, if every single person out there decided to "better" themselves and become <>, then there would be too many of them and you could very well be out of a job. So smarten up and realize that not everyone out there can be at the top of the food chain!
Ugh. Yeah. I could go on and on. lol It’s an extra sore topic because of current situations. When the mill first went down I had SO MANY people tell me to just move out West where the work is, like it’s such a simple thing to do. After a while I started answering these comments with, “So you want to buy my house, do you?”
[…] doing. It’s going to be a disaster for Atlantic Canada (read a good explanation here) and I really am thinking that the goal is to turn the region into a seaside resort for the wealthy […]